• Home
  • For Students
    • Current Scholars
    • Scholarship FAQs
    • Student Resources
  • For Grant Seekers
    • Grant Eligible Counties
    • Organizations Funded
  • For Friends & Followers
    • Tennessee Education Facts
    • Nashville Education Facts
      • Third-Grade Literacy in MNPS
      • School Data Finder
    • Grantee Success Stories
    • What We Are Reading
    • What We Are Learning
logologo

  • Nashville School Data Finder
  • About
    • Key Initiatives
    • Leadership
    • Financials
  • Contact Us
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Linked In
  • YouTube

  • Home
  • For Students
    • Current Scholars
    • Scholarship FAQs
    • Student Resources
  • For Grant Seekers
    • Grant Eligible Counties
    • Organizations Funded
  • For Friends & Followers
    • Tennessee Education Facts
    • Nashville Education Facts
      • Third-Grade Literacy in MNPS
      • School Data Finder
    • Grantee Success Stories
    • What We Are Reading
    • What We Are Learning
  • Home
  • For Students
    • Current Scholars
    • Scholarship FAQs
    • Student Resources
  • For Grant Seekers
    • Grant Eligible Counties
    • Organizations Funded
  • For Friends & Followers
    • Tennessee Education Facts
    • Nashville Education Facts
      • Third-Grade Literacy in MNPS
      • School Data Finder
    • Grantee Success Stories
    • What We Are Reading
    • What We Are Learning
logologo

  • Nashville School Data Finder
  • About
    • Key Initiatives
    • Leadership
    • Financials
  • Contact Us
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Linked In
  • YouTube

  • Home
  • For Students
    • Current Scholars
    • Scholarship FAQs
    • Student Resources
  • For Grant Seekers
    • Grant Eligible Counties
    • Organizations Funded
  • For Friends & Followers
    • Tennessee Education Facts
    • Nashville Education Facts
      • Third-Grade Literacy in MNPS
      • School Data Finder
    • Grantee Success Stories
    • What We Are Reading
    • What We Are Learning
November 30, 2018 News

Strategic Retention Of Effective Teachers And Leaders Critical To Success

One way that organizations improve is by making strategic decisions about their personnel: hiring good people, placing them where they can be most effective, supporting them, and holding on to them—or not, depending on their fit and their job performance. As two Tennessee Education Research Alliance (TERA) studies highlight, this thinking applies to schools and school districts as well.

First, as we describe in a recent TERA brief, school leadership plays an important role in teacher retention. To investigate this relationship, we merged information about teacher mobility in Tennessee with multiple measures of principal performance, including rubric-based practice ratings assigned to principals in TEAM and teachers’ assessments of leadership in their schools from the Tennessee Educator Survey.

The findings were stark. Tennessee teachers were more likely to “stick” in schools with highly rated leaders. But even more important: the most effective teachers were even more likely to stay under a strong leader, and, in contrast, the least effective teachers were actually more likely to turn over.

In other words, Tennessee’s most effective principals tend to strategically retain teachers. They do a better job of holding on to their best teachers, but they also find ways to remove struggling teachers or teachers who are not a good fit for the school, through “counseling out” or other means.

An interesting additional finding from our analysis is that the evidence of strategic retention was much stronger when measuring teacher effectiveness by classroom observation ratings than by value-added. We suspect that ratings are more informative for teacher retention because principals collect them themselves, and observation rubrics help principals think more specifically about which teachers are excelling and which are struggling.

Unfortunately, we find less evidence of this kind of strategic retention behavior in high-poverty, low-achieving schools—precisely the kinds of schools where exposure to a high-quality teacher can be especially meaningful for student outcomes. Being strategic is more challenging when finding replacement teachers is difficult. But a second TERA analysis points to another reason: districts also face strategic personnel challenges which lead them to place less effective principals in high-needs schools.

In this study, we examine the distribution of principal qualifications and performance measures across measures of school disadvantage (e.g., high poverty). Our clear conclusion is that principal quality is inequitably distributed in Tennessee. Districts tend not to place their most experienced and most effective principals in the highest need schools where they could potentially have the largest impact. Instead, across urban, suburban, and rural schools, we find that the least experienced, least effective principals are in the schools with the lowest achievement and highest concentrations of poverty.

This pattern arises in part because principals in the most disadvantaged schools turn over at higher rates and because districts tend to hire less experienced and less effective leaders into those schools when vacancies arise. For instance, schools with high poverty are much more likely to fill a principal vacancy with someone who has never been a principal before (principals typically are least effective in their first year when first learning the job). Across the state, more than 40 brand-new principals each year take over schools serving a student population that is more than 80 percent low-income.

Strategic personnel management in schools starts with strategic personnel management at the district level. Good teachers stay in schools with good principals. Recruiting and retaining excellent teachers in our highest-needs schools means ensuring that those school have effective leaders. And that means, first, getting strong leaders into high-needs schools a priority, then figuring out what incentives and supports they need to stay.

[Read more at SCORE]

Related Posts

Gov. Bill Haslam convened a ‘power meeting’ between Tennessee’s charter school and district leaders. Here’s why.

February 22, 2018
Read More

Metro Schools hosting events to increase diversity education

February 22, 2018
Read More

Letter From Jamie Woodson: Empowering Educators To Become The Advocates Tennessee Students Need

February 20, 2018
Read More

What Educators Gain From The Tennessee Educator Fellowship: Strength, Confidence, And Impact

February 19, 2018
Read More
In Tennesseee, black educators stick with teaching, but change schools more often says a new studyPrevious Post
Tennessee Releases New State Report CardNext Post

SIGN UP FOR OUR NEWSLETTER

Receive our latest updates

Quick Links

  • Home
  • About
  • For Students
  • For Grant Seekers
  • For Friends & Followers
  • Contact Us
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube

Mission

We advocate, invest, and work to ensure that all students in Middle Tennessee have access to a high-quality education.

© Copyright 2025 Scarlett Family Foundation. All Rights Reserved. | Privacy Policy

Scarlett Family FoundationLogo Header Menu
  • Home
  • About
    • Key Initiatives
    • Leadership
    • Financials
  • For Students
    • Current Scholars
    • Scholarship FAQ
    • Student Resources
  • For Grant Seekers
    • Organizations Funded
    • Grant Eligible Counties
  • For Friends & Followers
    • Grantee Success Stories
    • Tennessee Education Facts
    • Nashville Education Facts
      • Third-Grade Literacy in MNPS
      • School Data Finder
    • What We Are Reading
    • What We Are Learning
  • Nashville School Data Finder
  • Contact Us
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube